‘Natural Immunity Is Really Better’: New Israeli Study Fuels Debate On Vaccination Versus Natural Immunity

Authors: DYLAN HOUSMAN HEALTHCARE REPORTER August 28, 20215:12 PM ET

A new study of the power of COVID-19 natural immunity versus the protection provided by vaccines is igniting further debate among scientists on how to assess risk from the virus.

The observational study of more than 700,000 Israelis, which hasn’t yet been peer-reviewed, compared three groups: those who hadn’t been infected and received two doses of Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine, those who had been infected and were completely unvaccinated and individuals who were previously infected and received one dose of the vaccine. The researchers found that uninfected vaccine recipients were 13 times more likely to experience a breakthrough infection than those who were previously infected.

“It’s a textbook example of how natural immunity is really better than vaccination,” Charlotte Thålin, a physician and immunology researcher at Danderyd Hospital and the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, Sweden, told Science Magazine. “To my knowledge, it’s the first time [this] has really been shown in the context of COVID-19.”

Prior research has indicated that natural immunity to COVID-19 is strong, but no research has definitely shown that it is more protective than getting vaccinated up to this point.

The increased protection found in the study extended beyond reinfection, as natural immunity was also found to lead to fewer symptomatic cases and hospitalizations as well. The researchers also concluded that individuals who received one dose of the Pfizer vaccine in addition to recovering from previous infection had the highest level of protection of the three groups.

Data was pulled from Israel between June 1 and August 14, when the Delta variant was dominant in the country. The variant is currently driving a spike in cases and deaths in the United States. It is believed to be the largest real-world study conducted during the pandemic comparing natural immunity to vaccine protection. (RELATED: Poll: Anxiety Over COVID-19 At Highest Point Since Winter)

“The differences are huge,” added Thålin, although she warned the research couldn’t be considered conclusive. The sample size of hospitalizations in the 32,000-person analysis of the vaccinated group was only eight, and only one among the previously infected. Nobody in the entire study died, signaling that both vaccination and natural immunity provide a substantial amount of protection from death.

Researchers warned that the takeaway from the study should not be that catching COVID-19 is a superior substitute to getting vaccinated, due to the higher level of risk that comes with battling the virus versus getting the shot. “What we don’t want people to say is: ‘All right, I should go out and get infected, I should have an infection party,” Rockefeller University’s Michael Nussenzweig, an immunologist, told Science.

2 thoughts on “‘Natural Immunity Is Really Better’: New Israeli Study Fuels Debate On Vaccination Versus Natural Immunity

  1. Bandar judi slot online resmi CERIASLOT menyediakan berbagai jenis
    permainan judi online uang asli menggunakan apk slot online terbaru dengan mengakses browser melalui laptop computer maupun smartphone.
    Promo ini bertujuan untuk menambah jumlah anggota member dan juga memberikan tambahan tabungan saldo anda atau deposit kepada
    para pemain yang selalu aktif melakukan invite ke orang terdekat mereka yang sudah
    jadi member baru situs bandar judi slot online
    terpercaya kami. Saat hanya basa basi mari kita bicarakan tentang ini kami akan sediakan anda situs judi slot online
    jackpot terbesar, sudah barang tentu kita pasti
    merujuk ke Judi Online ligafox. Baiklah, mari kita
    mulai dengan mencoba memahami dasar-dasar permainan mesin online sehingga Anda memiliki gagasan yang sangat baik tentang keseluruhan proses.
    Mesin slot online terbaru, baik offline maupun slot online gacor, di mana bila ikon atau
    karakter pada garis payline tersebut berturut-turut sama, maka pemain berhak mendapatkan jackpot terbesar.

    Melihat dari website nawala dan ada kumpulan nama – nama
    situs judi slot online terpercaya, LIGAFOX ini akan memberikan anda promosi terbesar yang bisa anda klaim baik bagi new member atau
    member lama yang sudah bergabung situs slot kami. Saya yakin diantara para pembaca sekalian sudah mendengar kabar bahwa situs judi slot on-line menjadi situs permainan paling.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *